It’s October, which means it’s time to dust off the scary comics for some Halloween reading. In 1995 when The Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide reached its 25th edition, Robert M. Overstreet dug into the popular horror books to provide a list of the top 25 horror comics in Near Mint condition.

#1 – Vault of Horror #12 – $2,800
#2 – Tales of Terror Annual #1 – $2,600
#3 – Strange Tales #1 – $1,675
#4 – Journey into Mystery #1 – $1,575
#5 – Crypt of Terror #17 – $1,400
#5 – Haunt of Fear #15 – $1,400
#5 – Crime Patrol #15 – $1,400
#8 – War Against Crime #10 – $1,150
#9 – Tales of Terror Annual #2 – $1,100
#9 – Tales of Suspense #1 – $1,100
#9 – Tales to Astonish #1 – $1,100
#9 – House of Mystery #1 – $1,100
#13 – Crime Patrol #16 – $900
#13 – Crypt of Terror #18 – $900
#13 – Crypt of Terror #19 – $900
#16 – My Greatest Adventure #1 – $840
#17 – Tales of Terror Annual #3 – $825
#18 – Amazing Adventures #1 – $800
#19 – Tales of the Unexpected #1 – $790
#20 – Adventures into the Unknown #1 – $750
#20 – Eerie #1 – $750
#22 – Tales from the Crypt #20 – $725
#23 – Forbidden Worlds #1 – $700
#23 – War Against Crime #11 – $700
#25 – Vault of Horror #13 – $615